Darkness and Light: The Suicide Blog

My mother, who died in 2001, would have been 65 years old this past Sunday. I say died because that’s what happened to her. She didn’t ‘pass away’ as people are so fond of saying, as when an elderly person drifts off to peaceful sleep and simply doesn’t awaken. Most people in my life know already that my mother took her own life. They may or may not know that in our last conversation she was angry and disappointed with me, and that I was the one to find her body the following day.

I’ve come to understand that this is a more common experience than many people realize. I’ve never been a part of a suicide survivors group or anything like it, but I’ve still had two girlfriends who lost their mothers this way and several acquaintances who have lost loved ones to self-harm as well.

Homecoming Queen, 1965

When I was young and my mother (who battled her whole life with trauma and mental illness) would threaten or attempt to kill herself, I would run a gamut of emotional reactions, ranging from absolute desperation to keep her alive, all the way to a self-protecting cold acceptance. The first was totally unlivable; the latter became a hardness within me that I have both battled against and called upon for strength in later years.

Even now, I cannot imagine the kind of pain she must have been in: how desperate she must have felt herself, or how in her calmer moments she must have regretted the behaviors that put such a distance between us. In my calmer moments, the naive writer inside me thought suicide was sort of a romantic, noble end. I thought of Sylvia Plath and Virginia Woolf and their tortured beauty. Buddhist monks burning themselves to death in protest of the Vietnam War. Romeo and Juliet.

The reality, when it came years later, felt both shocking and inevitable. I was stunned and saddened by her death, but also ashamed that I felt something else on both our behalf: relief.  After years of threats and attempts and close calls, decades of walking on eggshells and bending myself into impossible knots trying to avoid this very thing… the thing had happened. It could never be undone, and it could never happen again. As we said goodbye and scattered her ashes in a garden, I could not hold back the thought: It’s done. She can never hurt me like this again.

It does hurt again, though. Over and over. I’ve written before about the longing I feel almost daily for my mother – whether it’s the mother she was or the mother I wished for, I will never be sure. When I first heard my sons’ cries in the delivery room, they echoed with her absence. She missed comforting me through a painful divorce, she missed meeting the true love of my life and father of my children, she missed my journey to Judaism and all the richness that has come with it. She has missed about a thousand nights or days when I have wanted to pick up the phone to call her: for advice, for comfort, for a laugh, for the gossip she was always willing to relate (with her own peppering of outrage, of course).

My parents, Huntsville, AL 1973

She missed the death of my father, with whom I firmly believe she was always in love and vice versa, even years after their divorce. I like to think they’re together now, watching our kids and laughing at our trials. These things could be any story of a parent lost early, except there is an additional and painful element: choice. She chose to miss these things. At least, that’s how it feels in my moments of anger.

Survivors of suicide are entitled to our anger. Nothing hurts quite so much as being left voluntarily by someone who was supposed to love you forever. You find yourself constantly wondering what you could have done differently, how you might have saved the person from their pain. You wonder what you did wrong. And all the platitudes and kind voices and “there, there, it wasn’t about you,” in the world don’t make that feeling go away. At least not entirely.

Twelve years later, and after working in a profession in which part of my job was to prevent people harming themselves, I have come to realize something else about my mother and others like her. It’s almost ironic that my mother had Dissociative Identity Disorder (previously known as Multiple Personality Disorder) because in her true self state, she had almost no filter, no ability to be disingenuous. Maybe her brain needed to allow her to be more than one person because she had no ability to be anyone other than herself on purpose.

My mother didn’t tell little conversational white lies or make small talk like the rest of us do. She didn’t pretend to be interested when she wasn’t, and she could not turn off the caring and empathic part of herself that reached out to all those in pain. If she asked “how are you?” it’s because she really wanted to know. She could not walk away from a homeless person with a story to tell. She could not watch her poor neighbors go hungry even when she could barely feed herself. Until my father insisted that she stop, she picked up hitchhikers in our family van, even with my brother and me in the backseat.

For Mom, there was nothing about herself that was better or higher than anyone else, nothing that could be kept separate from the injustice she saw in the world. In the psychology realm, we would label this as a ‘boundary issue.’ That is true in terms of her own mental health, but it’s also true that the world needs people like my mother. In many ways, her giving of her whole self to the world around her was the living example of the human spirit. She was the embodiment of the Jewish concept of Tzedakah, which means both ‘charity’ and ‘justice.’

We need her and others like her, even though they wound us so deeply by not caring enough for themselves. My mother gave herself over to pain because that was her experience of reality, and yet she kept her faith in God, the world, my brother and others (and, I hope, in me).

I believe there are people in this world who feel things more deeply, more personally, than most of us can bear to do. Whatever the reasons, whatever the causes, they carry with them a kindness and vulnerability so deep that it is both a treasure and a burden. They either don’t have or don’t use the protective filter that “healthy” people use to turn off pain and heartache so that we can function. (Don’t get me wrong, the world needs us, too — someone has to keep things working and stay strong for those who are not strong themselves).

I believe we have to learn from those among us like my mother, those who might be labeled as ‘too sensitive,’ ‘impractical’ or even ‘crazy.’ We can learn from their artistic talents, unbridled empathy and sense of justice, because we need those to maintain our basic humanity. We also have to help ground them and keep them safe and strong when we can.

But we can’t always.

Sometimes their burden is simply too much to bear. Sometimes the depth of their feelings becomes an abyss from which they cannot return, even though they might desperately want to come back to us. Sometimes we must stand at the edge and say goodbye, realizing that we cannot change who they are, nor can we alter or even fully understand their fate. We have to bear our own burden of their loss, with as much grace and genuineness as we can muster.

When my mom died, the world truly lost a light of love. It was extinguished in the darkness of her own personal torment, gone to a place I cannot know or understand. As for me, I will keep my filters and boundaries and “healthy” mental state – such as it is. I will stay strong for my family for as long as I am able, because hers will not be my fate. But I will think of Mom when we put coins in our Tzedakah box, and whenever I have an opportunity to create justice in my own little corner of the world.

I cannot bring her light back to our lives, but I can try to rekindle it in the family she never got to know. We can build on her legacy, and in that sense, the light will never really go out.

MJ Pullen

M.J. Pullen is a distracted writer and the mom of two boys in Roswell, Georgia, where she is absolutely late for something important right now. Her books include quirky romantic comedies and playful women's fiction. She blogs erratically with writing advice, random observations, and reflections on raising very loud kids and dogs. Join her Distracted Readers newsletter list for updates, free content, giveaways and more.

19 thoughts on “Darkness and Light: The Suicide Blog”

  1. Cathy KunstCathy Kunst

    Manda, that was very touching and well written.I am sorry you had to experience something so traumatic.I know we have never met, but I have known Brenda,Sam and Anna for about 30 or so yrs. and love them like family. I am happy you and Sam found each other and you had 2 beautiful sons!Bless you and your family,have a great day!

  2. Jeff LuceJeff Luce

    Wonderful post Manda.

  3. BrendaBrenda

    Perfect.

  4. RobinRobin

    Manda, you are such a strong and brave daughter, mother and wife. Your ability to express your personal experience with such wisdom and passion is amazing,Sending you a big hug!

  5. Lynne ParsonLynne Parson

    Amanda, I did not know your mother, only your father. But your insight into what she must have been feeling and your own feeling and emotions have so much wisdom that I am sure your mother is very proud of you as am I. You have such a wonderful way with words that you can make the reader feel with all the empathy you must feel. You have matured into a fine young woman and your family is very blessed to have you. Love you. Lynne

  6. Julie BowersJulie Bowers

    Thank you, valuable pearls you are willing to risk sharing.

  7. Stacey HerreraStacey Herrera

    I have been thinking so much of Peggy in the last few days – and of you and Eric. I still remember the phone call and the shock that she had finally done it. You have written, as you always do, so eloquently and have shared important insights into the feelings of family and friends. When Peggy was “herself” she was one of the most fun and loving people that I have ever known. I, too, like to picture her with Kerry watching over us all. Hugs and love to you my sister.
    Mimi

  8. Judy Caplan GinsburghJudy Caplan Ginsburgh

    Thanks, Manda. I really enjoy your writings and will be sharing this one with my rabbinic colleagues. I really hope we get to meet one day. We need to have a cousins reunion in Georgia!

  9. Vilda BrannenVilda Brannen

    Manda, Thanks for sharing your heart and pain in your beautifully chosen words. As a Mom, I know she loved and sometimes that made life even more difficult to face with a mental illness. How many times have I heard clients say to me–“My family would be better off without me.” I assure them this is not the case, but I don’t have the power to keep anyone from leaving this life if an illness causes them to think this way. I did not know your Mom, but I know you and your zest for life, love, marriage, family and kids. I am sure your Mom lives on in the midst of everything you do. Her imprint on you was not one of your choosing, but it certainly has helped to form the wonderful young woman you have become. I honor her today along with others who have died because of a mental illness–not necessarily their choices but the result of their diseases. Keep the faith. Your pain is not wasted.

  10. Gail SchellGail Schell

    Manda, your way with words is always impressive, but never more powerful than in this piece. You speak so honestly about your Mom and the relationship you had with her. I’m sure that alone is helpful to others who have shared your experience. Your perspective, earned at such a cost, is invaluable. I wish everyone could read this.

  11. Jerry BassJerry Bass

    Mandy,
    I did know your mom. We graduated from high school together. I think (if my memory serves me correctly) our pictures are in our high school album as superlatives in the category of “Best All Around.” I left Georgia a long time ago and have lived in New Orleans all these years. I did go back to a class reunion many years ago (one of our first) and a few days later your mother called me out here in New Orleans. I hardly remember our conversation but suppose she was “reaching out” since I am a Christian minister. We sat next to each other at the reunion & had conversation, but I didn’t know all she was going through. My prayers are with you as you continue to process all of this. Your blog is tremendous. I have fond memories of your mom during our school days.

  1. A Brief Note of Thanks + Robin Williams Tribute Video - MJ Pullen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.